My First Nokona^™ - Pumpkin Spice

Evidence public reviews and break reports, with links

Public reviews of Nokona are plentiful. They are gathered by maker; each source says which product or line it covers.

• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: Alpha S-200 youth 11.25 inRating: 4.68 of 5 (page shows 4.6785714)Reviews: 56Buyers like: Leather quality is the most consistent praise: soft, well crafted, American made; Break-in: most say it is game-ready after a week or two of catch; a few needed longer, especially without conditioner; Fits small hands well and feels light; Many expect several seasons of use or to hand it downBuyers report: Price is the most common complaint; Youth closing effort: a few parents of younger kids found the squeeze hard to manage and one said the ball kept slipping out; Sizing mixed: some say it runs small, others say it measured near 11 in and was too big for a young child; Palm padding called thin by several; Some report a sloppy pocket within months, lacing failure after a season, fingers spreading, or a glove needing a warranty rebuild; One reviewer unhappy with the maker's responsiveness on a warranty issue; Limited left-hand options (read it there)
• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: Alpha S-V1 youth 11.25 in5.0 of 5, 7 reviewsBuyers like: Break-in: ready within days to about five practices, no conditioner needed per two reviewers; Youth closing effort: adjustable Velcro strap praised for small hands (closing effort itself not described); Leather called high-end and American made; One parent says it outlasted a mid-tier Rawlings that began to tearBuyers report: Price is the only recurring drawback; Q&A (not reviews) warns kids with larger hands may find the youth fit tight (read it there)
• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: Pro Line PL-1200C 12 inRating: 4.87 of 5 (page shows 4.8695652)Reviews: 23Buyers like: High-quality, soft, well-made leather; appealing smell and color; Keeps its shape; reviewers expect it to last for yearsBuyers report: Break-in split: some say quick, others say longer than competing models; several recommend the maker's conditioner; Heavier than many gloves; Runs small, some measured under the listed 12 in; one order returned over sizing; Color can fade without regular conditioning (read it there)
• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: Classic Walnut WB-1175 11.75 inRating: 4.81 of 5 (page shows 4.8125)Reviews: 16Buyers like: Leather consistently praised as high quality and soft once broken in; American craftsmanship valued; Holds shape and pocket well for mostBuyers report: Break-in: a few sessions of catch for some, a month or more for others, one needed conditioner treatments; One reviewer said it turned flimsy after about a month of heavy use; Possible slight undersizing (one) and a fit that felt large for a second baseman (one) (read it there)
• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: Legend Pro L-1200 12 in5.0 of 5, 1 reviewBuyers like: Break-in about 2 to 3 weeks, though pinky and thumb stayed stiff; reviewer found it noticeably less stiff than a Wilson A2000; Sturdy leather expected to lastBuyers report: None listed (read it there)
• JustBallGlovesRetailer ratings: American Legend AL-1175 11.75 in5.0 of 5, 2 reviewsBuyers like: Leather and build quality praised; holds its shape; Break-in about one to two weeks per one reviewerBuyers report: Fingers uncomfortable at first until the glove was shaped (one) (read it there)
• Sports Unlimited (retailer-authored guide)Other source: Nokona Classic Walnut vs Wilson A2000The source says: Guide says Nokona breaks in faster than Wilson and is American made, with a 1-year factory warranty