Should I buy a 2 5/8 or a 2 3/4 barrel bat?

It depends on the league. A 2-3/4 in barrel is allowed only in USSSA 14U and under; Little League, Cal Ripken / Babe Ruth, DYB, PONY, High school and College allow 2-5/8 in at most.

The largest barrel by league

LeagueLargest barrel
Little League Minors, Majors2-5/8 in
Little League Intermediate (50/70), Junior2-5/8 in
Cal Ripken / Babe Ruth Cal Ripken2-5/8 in
Cal Ripken / Babe Ruth Babe Ruth 13-162-5/8 in
DYB2-5/8 in
PONY2-5/8 in
USSSA 14U and under2-3/4 in
High school2-5/8 in
College2-5/8 in

Where this comes from

Every rule, with its source, is on How the fit works.

More in bat guides