Tater Baseball, made in Cheshire, Connecticut, USA, approx. 8–10 weeks

First Base Mitt

12.5 in
Web Modified Pro-H
Break-in not stated
Closing not stated

Facts as the maker states them, read 13 Oct 2026

First base mitt in premium high-grade leather with a Modified Pro-H web, listed at 12.5 inches and made in Cheshire, Connecticut. The page offers custom web, palm, back, and lace colors plus embroidered numbers, initials, or team marks.

Type	First base mitt
Size	12.5 in What this means Measured from the heel to the top of the index finger. Infielders use smaller gloves (10.25 to 11.75 in) for quick transfers; outfielders larger (12 to 12.75 in); first base and catcher's mitts are measured differently. Tip: Bigger is not better for a young infielder. A glove they can close beats a glove that looks like a pro's.
Web	Modified Pro-H
Leather	Premium high-grade leather
Custom	Yes
Also on the page	Customization: Color, lace, embroidery Mitts have no individual fingers, run longer, and use deeper pockets shaped for scooping rather than fielding grounders
Warranty	Manufacturer warranty included
Lead time	Approx. 8–10 weeks
Availability	Made to order
Made in	Cheshire, Connecticut, USA
The maker says	If you play first base, this is the build you want. Premium leather, hand-finished in Connecticut, customized to your spec. Built to secure picks on low throws. Molds to your hand the first season.
Source	taterbaseball.com, product page, read 13 Oct 2026

Pat's Grade one person's opinion, with the reason

Not yet graded

Patrick has not graded this line yet. A line not handled yet says Not yet graded, never a low grade.

We have no dealer or affiliate relationship with Tater Baseball. If that changes it will say so here, and the grade will not move. How we grade

Evidence public reviews and break reports, with links

Public reviews of Tater Baseball are thin. They are gathered by maker; each source says which product or line it covers.

What "buyer reports" means

Public review counts and themes we found for this maker, with links, plus break reports sent in by site users. Where we found nothing public we say so.

Tater Baseball (maker site)On the maker's own site, chosen by the maker: Stock maple wood batsRating: X12 Pro 4.7, X6 Pro 4.9, Torpedo wood bat 4.8 (all out of 5)Reviews: 83 (X12 Pro), 35 (X6 Pro), 13 (Torpedo)Liked on the maker's site: Balance and pop; Quality and design; Customer service; Long-term use without trouble (per testimonials)
ThingtestingOther source: Brand page0 reviews

Also checked, with no ratings or themes to report: Tater Baseball (maker site).

Break reports from players on this site

0 break reports so far.

Report a break