Throat Guard

Evidence public reviews and break reports, with links

Public reviews of All-Star are there, in moderate numbers. They are gathered by maker; each source says which product or line it covers.

• CatchersHome.com (Scott Perry; published Jan 9, 2024, updated Sep 18, 2026; affiliate-supported)Independent review: Best youth catcher's sets, includes System7 AxisThe review likes: Axis leg guards strong, breathable, lightweight and stay in place; DeltaFlex harness meant for a close fit; sized for 9-12 and 12-16; Only set in the roundup with a throat guardThe review raises: Higher cost is the only listed con (read it there)
• WalmartRetailer ratings: System7 Axis NOCSAE adult two-tone set (a second Axis Pro adult listing, walmart.com/ip/476508134, showed identical 4.8 / 69 / 61 numbers, so counted once)Rating: 4.8 of 5Reviews: 69 ratings, 61 written reviews (88% five-star, 9% four-star, 3% one-star)Buyers like: Fit is the most mentioned topic: generally true to size, including a 6-foot teen who found it fit well; Comfortable and did not bind when catching; Materials and construction described as high quality (10 mentions); Strong protection, especially leg coverageBuyers report: One neutral note: leg guards protect well but can feel restrictive; Two 1-star ratings with no visible text (read it there)
• WalmartRetailer ratings: Youth System7 Axis catchers kit (navy/scarlet)Rating: 4.7 of 5Reviews: 36 ratings, 33 written reviews (81% five-star, 14% four-star, 3% one-star)Buyers like: Reviewers call it top quality, durable with secure connections, and the best gear they have used; Good value and good color optionsBuyers report: One 1-star rating with no visible text (read it there)
• WalmartRetailer ratings: S7 Axis ages 9-12 (red)Rating: 4.8 of 5Reviews: 22 ratings, 21 written reviews (82% five-star)Buyers like: Parents of 10 and 12 year olds say it fits well and is adjustable; Child feels confident and protected behind the plate; Looks sturdy and has held up better than a previous setBuyers report: Leg guards slightly long for one young player, still usable; One 3-star rating with no visible text (read it there)
• WalmartRetailer ratings: S7 Axis youth ages 9-12 (red/white/blue)Rating: 4.3 of 5Reviews: 12 ratings, 10 written reviews (67% five-star, 17% three-star, 8% one-star)Buyers like: Fits young catchers with room to grow (a solid 9-year-old); Not restrictive from first wear; helmet praised; seen as an upgrade over older gearBuyers report: One 1-star and two 3-star ratings with no visible text; Aftermarket knee-saver straps were heavier than the factory straps (one buyer); Listing text disagrees with itself on age range (9-12 versus 12-16) (read it there)
• Baseball MonkeyRetailer ratings: All-Star catcher's gear listingRating: 90% (System 7 Pro adult 2020 set); 35% (System 7 Axis Solid Pro intermediate 2020 set)Reviews: 1 review eachBuyers report: The 35% rating on the intermediate set has no visible text (read it there)
• Sports UnlimitedRetailer ratings: System7 Axis Senior Pro catcher's kitRating: 5 (in page data, not a clear visible widget)Reviews: 1
• Better BaseballRetailer ratings: The Donut 33.5 in catcher training mitt0 visible
• Sports Unlimited (retailer-authored)Other source: All-Star vs Easton youth catcher's gearThe source says: Describes the All-Star helmet cage, chest plates and gel knee pad as protective features; declares no winner